The Ultimate Fire Island Bucket List

The Sunken Forest
In a little world of its own, Fire Island has its compelling charm and unique allure. With pristine beaches, maritime forests, and an atmosphere that effortlessly transitions from serene to vibrant, Fire Island is a gem that requires a ferry ride to reach — a small effort but definitely worth the trip! Notably, this island is renowned for its LGBTQ+-friendly locales like Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines, enhancing its appeal and diversity!
I’ve decided to make a bucket list for Fire Island because even though this island is tiny, there’s SO much to discover and do — which is perfect for unforgettable experiences!
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
for Adventures

Sunken Forest
Right at Sailors Haven, the Sunken Forest is a must-visit spot!
It's an extraordinary maritime forest ecosystem, where ancient American Holly trees, some over 300 years old, reign supreme. The forest is "sunken" behind the dunes, creating a unique and mesmerizing atmosphere.
Just remember to apply mosquito spray before you head into the Sunken Forest — because there’s a TON of them there.

Fire Island Lighthouse
This iconic lighthouse, located on the Kismet side of the island, holds the title of both the tallest lighthouse on Long Island and one of its oldest!
Head to the top for some breathtaking panoramic views. You might even see the Manhattan skyline from there.
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
for Beach-lovers

Cherry Grove
An LGBTQ+ favorite! And get this: even though it’s not technically a nude beach, you’ll see people sunbathing nude — so feel free to let loose!
If you’re hungry, no worries — there's a bunch of food joints nearby. Once you're done eating, just stroll over to the beach and bathe in the sun.
It's all about good times and relaxation at Cherry Grove!

Kismet Beach
If you’re looking for a more chill beach experience, Kismet Beach would be your best bet!
Unlike some of the other beaches on Fire Island, Kismet offers more of a laid-back kinda experience with fewer crowds, is pet-friendly (a big plus!), and is perfect for soaking up the summer sun!
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
for Foodies

drink a Rocket Fuel
Fire Island not only has great beaches and cute villages, but also its legendary cocktail — the Rocket Fuel!
This drink was created in Ocean Beach at CJ's in the 1980s and remains a local favorite 🍹

Kismet Inn
After a refreshing swim at Kismet Beach, head straight to the legendary Kismet Inn for some yummy seafood.
This iconic Fire Island family-owned restaurant is renowned for seafood and live music!
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
more bucket list ideas!
Ocean Beach - lots of rules — “The Land of No”… no food or drinks except water on the beach. No pets on the beach. No swimming without a lifeguard. No flying kites. No playing music. 😂
Sailors Haven — no dogs allowed.
Robert Moses State Park
Take a water taxi
Sail around Sailors Haven
Drive across the Fire Island Inlet Bridge
Ride a bike around Fire Island! 🏝️
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
-
National Park Service: Sunken Forest
Fire Island: Cherry Grove
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
check out my Culebra travel vlog!
⋆ ˚ 🐚 🫧 𖦹 ⋆ 🥥
DISCOVER MORE
Ready to try something new? Gotham Archery lets you unleash your inner Robin Hood. Perfect for beginners, their introductory classes will have you hitting the bullseye in no time. 🎯
Enjoy breathtaking skyline views, relaxing picnic spots, and a taste of history. Bike scenic trails, dine at waterfront gems like Taco Vista, and make it a perfect day trip.
Step into a world where art comes to life! The Nasher Sculpture Center in Dallas showcases breathtaking sculptures and immersive exhibitions that will leave you inspired.
From the iconic Grand Staircase to masterpieces like Madame X and Albert Bierstadt’s breathtaking landscapes, there’s something to inspire every visitor.
Step into the New Museum, where innovative contemporary art meets bold architecture in the heart of Manhattan. Discover groundbreaking exhibitions and experience an artistic spot like no other.
Calling all stationery lovers! Visit Yoseka Stationery in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, where you can try before you buy! From premium fountain pens to charming washi tapes, this store offers a curated selection of high-quality Asian stationery that will elevate your collection.
Sink your toes into the soft, powdery sands of Kismet Beach on Fire Island. With crystal-clear waters, relaxing sunbathing spots, and perfect waves, it’s the ultimate destination for beach lovers. 🌊☀️
With crystal-clear waters, soft white sand, and breathtaking views, this secluded beach is perfect for nature lovers and adventurers alike.
Last Updated: 02.07.2025
Craving a quiet beach escape in Vietnam? Dam Trau Beach on Con Dao Island is where emerald waters meet soft sand and folklore lingers in the breeze. From secret crabs to fresh guava juice, this guide has everything you need to relax, explore, and stay awhile. ☁️🌊